One of the big policy issues for the federal government this year, as well as in the Conservative leadership race, is immigration. It’s an area worthy of attention.
By a margin of 63 to seven per cent, according to a recent Leger poll, Conservative voters want their new leader to decrease rather than increase immigration to Canada (the other 30 per cent were indifferent or didn’t know).
The calls for more restrictions on immigration, however, should be rejected in favour of a more open policy that allows for greater personal and economic freedom.
Given the consensus view of good economists that free trade is eminently desirable and a main driver of the economic progress achieved around the world for the past two centuries, it follows that the free movement of labour across borders is also a good thing.
Having a more open immigration policy is one of the easiest ways the federal government can increase economic freedom, improve economic growth and cut poverty. The main economic effect of a more open immigration system would be to allow labour to move to where it’s most productive and to make available to Canadians more opportunities and options in their economic dealings.
Some people argue that immigration is economically harmful because immigrants ‘steal’ jobs from domestic workers and drive down wages. This is nonsense. If immigrants are economically harmful because they take jobs away from domestic workers, then by the same logic, grocery stores are economically harmful because they take work away from families by eliminating their need to grow their own food.
A more serious economic objection to immigration is the potential cost: immigrants might represent a significant burden to taxpayers if they consume more government services than they pay for through taxes. This concern, while often exaggerated by opponents of immigration, is valid. However, it doesn’t justify a more restrictive immigration policy.
One solution, proposed by Gary Becker, is that if immigrants represent a net cost to taxpayers, then the government should simply sell the right to immigrate (while still allowing some free immigration for humanitarian purposes).
The current system, or a more restrictive one that denies many people the right to immigrate, effectively charges a cost of infinity to many people who want to move to Canada. But if an immigrant is expected to cost taxpayers $20,000, for example, then selling the right to immigrate for $20,000 is surely much more reasonable than setting the price at infinity.
An even better solution is to reduce the fiscal burden on taxpayers by curtailing the government programs creating the burden. Some people have argued, for example, that Canada’s public health-care system would be unable to handle the extra demand created by immigration unless much more money is raised through tax hikes. However, this is really a health-care spending problem, not an immigration problem.
Canada’s health-care system – a government monopoly – lacks competition, prices, costs to consumers and a normal labour market. Because of this, it’s doomed to inefficiency, excessive costs and a substandard level of service regardless of how much immigration there is.
The problem of too much government control in health care (and other areas) should not and cannot be solved by having more government control of immigration.
If the goal is to reduce poverty and strengthen the economy, we should want less government control and more economic freedom – and that includes allowing more immigration.
Matthew Lau is a research associate with the Frontier Centre for Public Policy.
© Troy Media – All Rights Reserved
Trusted editorial content provider to media outlets across Canada
Terms and Conditions of use
FREE MembershipDownload all of our FREE content and pay only for the BASIC and PREMIUM membership content you want.BASIC Membership$69.95/moDownload ALL of our content EXCEPT our PREMIUM content. Charge billed to your Paypal or credit card monthlyPREMIUM Membership$119.95/moDownload ALL of our content . Charge billed to your Paypal or credit card monthly
DON’T GO YET!
SAVE TIME! We can BROADCAST this content directly to your web site. Contact us for details.